4 Reasons Why Canadian Household Debt Isn't So Bad

Canadian household debt levels continue to be a hot button topic for policy-makers and media commentators alike. While concern is warranted, the situation is not nearly as dire as some might lead you to believe.

Not interested? Hurtful, but fair enough - here's a funny cat video instead. Interested? Read on...

The Situation

Canada’s household debt to disposable income ratio recently hit a record high of 165.92. This means that, for every after-tax dollar Canadian households earn in a year, they owe about $1.66.

Why is that not so bad? (Coles Notes version)

  1. Debt levels are not rising rapidly, it's just that income growth is even slower

  2. The debt we are taking on is low-interest mortgage debt, which is less expensive to service

  3. Assets are rising faster than debt, leading to growing net worth

  4. Canadians are making financially prudent decisions such as taking money out of their homes to pay off riskier, higher-interest debt

If you would like more than just the Coles Notes, the remainder of this post explains further. If not, there's always the cat video.

1. Debt Isn’t Ballooning Out of Control

While the level of debt is high, the growth rate of debt isn’t. In fact, after adjusting for inflation and population growth, debt has only been growing at around 2% per year for the last 5 years (see chart below). Furthermore, much of the growth in debt occurred during the mid 2000s, which was tempered by a series of tightened lending restrictions that began in 2008.

The chart below shows real, annual, per-capita debt growth for Canadian households, broken out by type of debt. The black line is total debt growth, which is the sum of the components. contributions to real, per-capita debt growth The reason we still have a rising debt to income ratio stems more from slow income growth, rather than rapid debt growth. Over the past 5 years income only rose by 1% a year, while debt rose by 2% - slowly increasing Canada’s household debt to income ratio.

2. Even Though We Have More Debt, We Aren’t Paying More for It

It’s true that we continue to take on more mortgage debt, however, we aren’t paying more for it. Record low interest rates mean that we are actually using less of our income to pay interest on our debt.

The chart below shows the percentage of Canadian after-tax income that goes to interest payment on debt. Falling levels mean that less of our income goes towards debt payments. more debt, less interest Essentially, while the level of our debt has risen, the burden of it has fallen.

3. Debt Is Only Half of the Equation – Assets Have Risen by More, Leaving Us Wealthier

While some of our debt has gone towards retail sales, much of it has been used to acquire assets, such as homes. The value of these assets has risen by more than our debt, leaving us wealthier as a nation.

The graph below shows the ratio of household assets to household debts. A rising value indicates that assets are rising faster than debts. household debts increasing faster than debt For a more detailed analysis on this subject, look to work from the Fraser Institute.

4. We Have Used Some of That Wealth to Consolidate Other Debt

As of late, a larger portion of our debt growth has stemmed from equity take-out (HELOCs, re-financed mortgages, etc.), as opposed to new mortgage originations. As our homes have appreciated in value, some Canadians have chosen to re-allocate that wealth elsewhere

The graph below shows average annual gross mortgage debt growth (not including the effects of principal payments)

What we have done with this money is crucial. The majority of equity take-out has been for the purpose of debt consolidation, with renovation and investments also accounting for significant proportions.

While there is valid reason to question to the accumulation of non-mortgage debt in the first place, the consolidation of it into low-interest mortgage debt undoubtedly makes household finances more sustainable and less risky.

*The infographic below shows equity take out over the last year. For a more detailed breakdown, click here whos taking what out

So What’s the Concern?

I don’t mean to come off as blasé about household debt, because there are some legitimate reasons for concern:

  1. Interest payments are low because of record low interest rates. Increases in interest rates could cause a rise in the arrears rate (the % of debt holders missing payments). This leaves the Bank of Canada’s in a precarious position when it comes time to raise rates, though that doesn’t look likely in the near future

  2. Increases in wealth have largely come from rising house prices, which have partially supported retail spending and renovation. Slower equity growth could impact this. It is worth noting, however, that most renovation spending is not financed anyway – mitigating the potential impact from slower home price growth

  3. While aggregate data is not overly concerning, the distribution of debt across households is of some concern. Analysis from the CD Howe Institute sheds some interesting light on this subject

What is important to emphasize here is that these are concerns revolving around Canadian households’ ability to weather negative exogenous shocks, rather than debt levels themselves causing a crisis.

High debt levels are more of a vulnerability than a trigger.